◆Smart Home Ideas Journal

Recreate Kmart's Sub at Home: Copycat Recipe

By

Craving the distinctive, Kmart-exclusive KMART Sub but can't get to the store, or just curious about recreating it at home? Today, we're diving into the world of copycat recipes with a detailed, SEO-optimized guide on replicating this beloved sandwich. Let's get started!

You might be wondering why you'd want to make a KMART Sub at home. Well, aside from saving money and the satisfaction of creating your own culinary masterpiece, there's something genuinely rewarding about enjoying a familiar sub sandwich with all the flavors you love, in the comfort of your own home. So, let's roll up our sleeves and get cooking!

The Search for the Perfect KMART Sub Copycat Recipe

Before we dive into our copycat recipe, it's important to understand what makes a KMART Sub unique. From the soft, sub-style bread to the perfect balance of flavors, this isn't just any sub sandwich – it's a KMART classic. Our goal? To capture its essence in our homemade version.

a sub sandwich with lettuce and tomato on it next to some potato chips
a sub sandwich with lettuce and tomato on it next to some potato chips
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Lunch Counter Classic
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Lunch Counter Classic
an advertisement for a kmart sub sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes
an advertisement for a kmart sub sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes

After extensive research and experimentation, we're confident our copycat recipe is as close as it gets to the original. So, let's break it down, step by step.

Finding the Right Bread

One of the most crucial elements of a KMART Sub is the bread. You'll want a soft, yet sturdy sub roll that can hold all the delicious filling without getting soggy. Our recommendation? Use a Portuguese-style sub roll or a classic Italian sub roll. If you're feeling adventurous, you can even make your own! Just ensure it has a soft, chewy interior and a crisp crust.

Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
CopyKat - 🥪 Nostalgic for the classic Kmart deli sub? Recreate this beloved sandwich at home with our spot-on copycat recipe! Layers of savory meats, gooey cheese, and crisp veggies piled high on a soft roll. Link in first comment. | Facebook Beef Dip, Copykat Recipes, Gooey Cheese, Wrap Sandwiches, Copycat Recipes, Sandwiches, Rolls, Meat
CopyKat - 🥪 Nostalgic for the classic Kmart deli sub? Recreate this beloved sandwich at home with our spot-on copycat recipe! Layers of savory meats, gooey cheese, and crisp veggies piled high on a soft roll. Link in first comment. | Facebook Beef Dip, Copykat Recipes, Gooey Cheese, Wrap Sandwiches, Copycat Recipes, Sandwiches, Rolls, Meat

For a more authentic experience, try and find a roll with a slight glow, similar to the KMART Sub's golden, toasted exterior. Achieve this by brushing the rolls with a light layer of butter or egg wash before baking or toasting.

Assembling the Perfect Toppings

Now that we have our perfect bread, let's move on to the star of the show – the toppings. The KMART Sub is known for its generous portion of deli meats and cheese, but what really sets it apart is the combination of flavors and textures. Here's our take on the classic KMART Sub topping combo:

  • Shaved turkey
  • Ham
  • Salami
  • Provolone cheese
  • Lettuce
  • Tomatoes
  • Onions
  • Pickles
  • Italy's Best Spread (See below for a copycat recipe)

Don't skimp on the toppings – remember, KMART Subs are legendary for a reason!

Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches

Italy's Best Spread: A KMART Sub Essential

The Italy's Best Spread is a staple on KMART Subs, adding a tangy, creamy kick that ties the whole sandwich together. While we don't have the official recipe, we've come close with our copycat version. Here it is:

  1. 1/2 cup mayonnaise
  2. 2 tbsp ketchup
  3. 1 tbsp yellow mustard
  4. 1 tbsp Worcestershire sauce
  5. 1/2 tsp paprika
  6. 1/2 tsp garlic powder
  7. 1/4 tsp black pepper

Simply whisk together all the ingredients in a small bowl until smooth. Taste and adjust as necessary. Spread a generous layer onto both insides of your sub roll before adding the toppings.

Putting It All Together

You've got your bread, your toppings, and your homemade Italy's Best Spread. Now let's layer it all up and create the perfect KMART Sub copycat.

the facebook page shows an image of several hamburgers with different toppings on them
the facebook page shows an image of several hamburgers with different toppings on them
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs
I grew up in Indiana | Anyone that grew up in Indiana and went to a Kmart has to remember their sub sandwich. | Facebook
I grew up in Indiana | Anyone that grew up in Indiana and went to a Kmart has to remember their sub sandwich. | Facebook
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Copycat Kmart Submarine Sandwiches
Copycat Kmart Submarine Sandwiches
Copycat Kmart Sub Recipe - The Food Hussy
Copycat Kmart Sub Recipe - The Food Hussy
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
a large sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes on it sitting on a plate
a large sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes on it sitting on a plate
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Original Kmart Subs
Original Kmart Subs

Start by spreading your Italy's Best Spread evenly on both halves of your sub roll. Then, heap on your deli meats – we like to alternate turkey, ham, and salami for a perfect balance of flavors. Top with a generous portion of provolone cheese, followed by lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and pickles. Don't forget, the key to a great KMART Sub is an abundance of toppings, so don't be shy!

Your Best Burst of Flavor: The Option to Toast

For an extra layer of flavor and a slightly crispy exterior, consider toasting your KMART Sub copycat. Simply assembly your sandwich without the top half of the roll, place it on a baking sheet, and broil for 2-3 minutes, keeping a close eye on it to avoid burning. Top with the second half of the roll, and serve immediately.

Whether you decide to toast or not, your homemade KMART Sub copycat is ready to be devoured. So go ahead, take a big bite, and enjoy the familiar flavors of this beloved sub sandwich, all from the comfort of your own home.

There you have it – our comprehensive guide to recreating the KMART Sub at home. Happy cooking, and until next time!