◆Smart Home Ideas Journal

Do Master Bathrooms Need a Tub?

By

The debate on whether master bathrooms need a bathtub often arises when planning a bathroom remodel or designing a new home. With the increasing prevalence of walk-in showers and spa-like bathrooms in modern home design, does a bathtub still hold its place in the master bathroom? Let's delve into this question, exploring both sides of the argument to help you make an informed decision.

Bathtubs have traditionally served multiple purposes – hygiene, relaxation, and even safety. However, the modern lifestyle and changing preferences have led many homeowners to question the necessity of a bathtub in their master bathroom. So, does a master bathroom really need a tub?

The Case Against Bathtubs

One of the primary reasons homeowners opt for bathtub-free master bathrooms is practicality. Showers are generally quicker and more water-efficient than baths, making them a practical choice for busy homeowners who prioritize time and conservation.

13 Master Bath Freestanding Tub Ideas for a True Retreat Without Renovating
13 Master Bath Freestanding Tub Ideas for a True Retreat Without Renovating
33 Master Bathroom 2026 Trends You'll Love to Try
33 Master Bathroom 2026 Trends You'll Love to Try
Robin’s Bathroom Makeover Reveal {Part One}
Robin’s Bathroom Makeover Reveal {Part One}

Space Considerations

Bathtubs, especially full-sized ones, take up considerable space. In smaller bathrooms, this space could be better utilized with a larger shower, double vanities, or more storage. Moreover, walk-in showers can create a more open, airy feel, making the bathroom feel larger.

Accessibility and Safety

For homeowners with mobility issues or those who plan to age in place, a walk-in shower can provide a safer, more accessible bathing option. Walk-in showers eliminate the need to step over a high tub wall, reducing the risk of slips and falls.

Master Bathroom Floorplan Ideas You Need to Know BEFORE You Start
Master Bathroom Floorplan Ideas You Need to Know BEFORE You Start
13 Neat Master Bath Wet Room 🚿✨
13 Neat Master Bath Wet Room 🚿✨
a bath room with a large tub and a fire place in the middle of it
a bath room with a large tub and a fire place in the middle of it

The Case For Bathtubs

Despite the shift towards showers, bathtubs still have their place in many master bathrooms. They offer several benefits that might outweigh the practical considerations, especially in the resale market.

Resale Value

Having at least one bathtub in your home can increase its resale value, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods. Buyers with young children or those who plan to start a family may prefer a home with bathtub options for bathing young ones.

Relaxation and Self-Care

After a long day, a warm bath can be an incredibly relaxing way to unwind. Whether it's with a good book, some candles, or a glass of wine, a bathtub can provide a luxurious, spa-like experience. Additionally, baths can ease muscle tension and help with joint pain, providing benefits for those with physically demanding jobs or chronic health conditions.

How to Make a No-Fail Luxury Master Bathroom for a Five-Star Feel at Home - 18 Ideas
How to Make a No-Fail Luxury Master Bathroom for a Five-Star Feel at Home - 18 Ideas
17 Master Bath Ideas for a Luxurious, Functional Retreat
17 Master Bath Ideas for a Luxurious, Functional Retreat
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower
Does My Home Really Need a Bath Tub? | Neil Kelly Blog
Does My Home Really Need a Bath Tub? | Neil Kelly Blog
Master Bathroom Ideas to Transform Your Space
Master Bathroom Ideas to Transform Your Space
30 Tub Beside Shower Ideas
30 Tub Beside Shower Ideas

Alternatives to Traditional Bathtubs

If you're hesitant to sacrifice the relaxation benefits of a bathtub but want the practicality and space-saving advantages of a shower, consider these alternatives.

Combination Tubs

Combination bathtub-shower units can provide the best of both worlds. You can have a relaxing bath when you want it, and still enjoy a walk-in shower when time is of the essence. Some combination units feature a low threshold for easy access, addressing the accessibility concerns as well.

Freestanding Tubs

Freestanding tubs can provide a luxurious, spa-like feel and take up less space than traditional built-in tubs. They can be placed anywhere in the bathroom, including in the center as a statement piece, or tucked into a nook. Freestanding tubs also come in various shapes and sizes, including claw-foot and slipper tubs, to fit with different design aesthetics.

13 Open Shower and Tub Ideas for a Wet-Room-Style Bathroom That Feels Bigger
13 Open Shower and Tub Ideas for a Wet-Room-Style Bathroom That Feels Bigger
a bathroom with a glass shower door and white tile flooring, along with a large walk in shower
a bathroom with a glass shower door and white tile flooring, along with a large walk in shower
Elegant Bathtub Bathroom Remodel Ideas (Before & After!)
Elegant Bathtub Bathroom Remodel Ideas (Before & After!)
I Asked AI to Design My $15,000 Dream Bathroom — Here’s What It Came Up With
I Asked AI to Design My $15,000 Dream Bathroom — Here’s What It Came Up With
21 Timeless Master Bath Ideas You'll Want to Save Forever
21 Timeless Master Bath Ideas You'll Want to Save Forever
90s Bathroom Makeover: Before & After Transformations
90s Bathroom Makeover: Before & After Transformations
a bathroom with a walk in shower next to a white tub and black tile floor
a bathroom with a walk in shower next to a white tub and black tile floor
Master Bath Ideas: Create a Luxurious Retreat
Master Bath Ideas: Create a Luxurious Retreat
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower next to a window on the wall
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower next to a window on the wall
Beautiful Bathroom Remodel Ideas and Design Trends for 2026
Beautiful Bathroom Remodel Ideas and Design Trends for 2026
Drop-In Bathtubs: Transform Your Bathroom Into a Luxe Retreat
Drop-In Bathtubs: Transform Your Bathroom Into a Luxe Retreat
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower
a bathroom with a large tub and walk in shower

Ultimately, whether a master bathroom needs a tub depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and specific needs. While showers are increasingly popular, bathtubs still provide unique benefits that might be worth considering. As for the design, there are creative alternatives that can cater to both relaxation and practicality. So, why not have it all in your master bathroom?