Amartya Sen, an acclaimed economist, philosopher, and Nobel laureate, is recognized for his significant contributions to welfare economics. Given his focus on capabilities and human development, one might wonder, is Amartya Sen a utilitarian?
Utilitarianism, as advocated by philosophers like Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, posits that the moral worth of an action should be evaluated based on its overall utility or benefit to society, typically measured in terms of happiness or pleasure. Sen's theories, however, depart from this definition in several ways.
Sen's Capability Approach
The core of Sen's thinking revolves around his capability approach, which holds that the primary objective of development is to enhance the capabilities of individuals to lead the lives they have reason to value. This is distinct from utilitarianism's focus on overall happiness.
In his influential work "Inequality Reexamined" and "Commodities and Capabilities," Sen argues that the value of a commodity lies not in what it can provide, but in what it enables individuals to do and be. This shift in perspective challenges the utilitarian assumption that utility is solely about the satisfaction of wants or desires.
Functionings and Capabilities
Sen's concept of 'functionings' - the various things a person may or may not be able to do or be, like being nourished or being educated - forms the bedrock of his capability approach. These functionings are made possible by a set of 'capabilities', the horas of real opportunities that a person has.
A person's well-being, according to Sen, is not determined by what they merely desire, but by what they can actually do and be. This is a significant departure from the utilitarian doctrine that focuses solely on the satisfaction of preferences.
The Role of Freedom and Agency
Sen's approach also emphasizes the importance of freedom and agency. It isn't just about what we should desire or choose, but what we should be free to choose. This emphasis on freedom and individual agency is another point of departure from utilitarianism, which often justifies paternalism in the name of overall utility.
In his prolific works like "Development as Freedom" and "The Idea of Justice," Sen further elaborates on this, asserting that development should be about expanding the real freedoms that people enjoy, and justice should be seen as a process of achieves to these freedoms.
Sen's Critique of Utilitarianism
Sen's capability approach can be seen as a critique of utilitarianism. He critiques the latter's focus on utility, arguing that it overlooks the importance of individual freedom and diversity in human values. His capability approach, instead, is a response to the perceived limitations of utilitarian ethics.
In "Collective Choice and Social Welfare," Sen critiques the conventional utilitarian approach of aggregating individual utilities, stating that it neglects the value of equality and the importance of procedural justice. He advocates instead for a more nuanced approach to social welfare measurement that incorporates the functionings and capabilities of all individuals.
"The ultimate test of the progress of a society," Sen writes in "Development as Freedom," "is not quantity of [GDP], but the quality of life, the richness of the lives people lead." This quote exemplifies Sen's focus on individual capabilities and freedoms, rather than the utilitarian measure of overall happiness or pleasure.