◆Smart Home Ideas Journal

Is It Cheaper to Replace Cabinets or Just the Doors

By

When updating kitchen cabinets, homeowners often wonder: is it cheaper to replace cabinets or just the doors? The answer largely depends on the current state of your cabinets and your specific design goals. Let's explore this cost-effective DIY conundrum.

Before delving into the costs, consider the condition and layout of your existing cabinets. If they're structurally sound and well-built, replacing just the doors and drawer fronts might be the way to go. However, if the cabinets are damaged, warped, or no longer functional, a full replacement might be necessary.

Assessing Your Cabinets

The first step in determining whether to replace cabinets or just the doors is to evaluate their current condition. Check for signs of wear, damage, or poor functionality.

Cabinet Refacing: Everything You Need to Know
Cabinet Refacing: Everything You Need to Know
Make your OLD cabinets looks NEW!
Make your OLD cabinets looks NEW!
How Affordable is Cabinet Refacing?
How Affordable is Cabinet Refacing?

Inspect for Wear and Tear

Look for scratches, nicks, and chipped paint on the doors and drawer fronts. These can usually be easily repaired or painted over if you're keeping the existing cabinets.

However, if the damage is extensive, it might be more cost-effective and aesthetically pleasing to replace just the doors and drawer fronts with new ones. This can completely transform the look of your kitchen without the hassle and expense of a full cabinet replacement.

the pros and cons of kitchen cabinet refaceing in this postcard
the pros and cons of kitchen cabinet refaceing in this postcard
DIY Reface Kitchen Cabinets Without Replacing Everything
DIY Reface Kitchen Cabinets Without Replacing Everything
Why Are Kitchen Cabinets So Expensive? (And Ways to Save)
Why Are Kitchen Cabinets So Expensive? (And Ways to Save)

Assess Structural Soundness

Check if the boxes (carcase) of your cabinets are level, plumb, and square. If they're well-built and stable, your existing cabinets might just need a facelift in the form of new doors and drawer fronts.

On the other hand, if the cabinets are sagging, wobbly, or not properly attached to the walls and floors, a full replacement might be necessary. Instability can lead to problems with door and drawer operation, as well as safety issues.

Cost Analysis: Replace Cabinets or Doors?

Once you've assessed the condition of your cabinets, it's time to crunch the numbers. Let's break down the costs associated with both options.

Cabinet Doors vs Refacing
Cabinet Doors vs Refacing
Is Cabinet Refacing Cheaper than Replacement?
Is Cabinet Refacing Cheaper than Replacement?
a white kitchen with the words which should you choose?
a white kitchen with the words which should you choose?
cabinets with the words how to update cabinets for cheap
cabinets with the words how to update cabinets for cheap
Upgrade Your Kitchen- Replace Cabinet Doors Easily!
Upgrade Your Kitchen- Replace Cabinet Doors Easily!
Cabinet Doors DIY Upgrade: How I Transformed My Kitchen | ThePlywood.com
Cabinet Doors DIY Upgrade: How I Transformed My Kitchen | ThePlywood.com

Cost of Replacing Cabinets

If a full cabinet replacement is necessary, the cost will vary depending on the materials, size, and quality of the cabinets. On average, homeowners spend between $500 and $1,500 per linear foot of new cabinets, including installation.

When budgeting for new cabinets, don't forget to factor in the cost of hardware, such as hinges, knobs, and drawer slides. Also, consider the cost of disposal or recycling your old cabinets if that's an option in your area.

Cost of Replacing Cabinets Doors Only

Replacing just the doors and drawer fronts is typically much more affordable than a full cabinet replacement. On average, homeowners spend between $100 and $400 per door, including the cost of new hardware.

The Cost of Replacing Kitchen Cabinet Doors in 2023
The Cost of Replacing Kitchen Cabinet Doors in 2023
a person is working on a cabinet door with the words how to replace kitchen cabinet doors for a new look
a person is working on a cabinet door with the words how to replace kitchen cabinet doors for a new look
Cabinet Door Replacement
Cabinet Door Replacement
What is Cabinet Refacing? Are you ready for a New Modern kitchen for the fraction of the price??
What is Cabinet Refacing? Are you ready for a New Modern kitchen for the fraction of the price??
Before and After: Cabinet Doors That Made My Kitchen Look Brand New
Before and After: Cabinet Doors That Made My Kitchen Look Brand New
Cabinet Door Replacement Can Help You Save Your Kitchen Remodeling Budget
Cabinet Door Replacement Can Help You Save Your Kitchen Remodeling Budget
Kitchen Cabinet Refacing: 6 Styles to Completely Transform Your Space
Kitchen Cabinet Refacing: 6 Styles to Completely Transform Your Space
The Advantages of Cabinet Door Replacement Instead of a Full Remodel
The Advantages of Cabinet Door Replacement Instead of a Full Remodel
Benefits to Cabinet Door Replacement & Cabinet Door Refacing
Benefits to Cabinet Door Replacement & Cabinet Door Refacing
How Much Does Cabinet Refacing Cost? A Complete Guide for Homeowners
How Much Does Cabinet Refacing Cost? A Complete Guide for Homeowners
Dated Cabinets? Consider Cabinet Door Replacement
Dated Cabinets? Consider Cabinet Door Replacement
Common Problems With Refacing Kitchen Cabinets
Common Problems With Refacing Kitchen Cabinets
The Basics of N-Hance Cabinet Door Replacement
The Basics of N-Hance Cabinet Door Replacement
Quick, Affordable Kitchen Update? Try Replacing Cabinet Doors
Quick, Affordable Kitchen Update? Try Replacing Cabinet Doors

However, keep in mind that the cost can increase if you need to purchase new filler strips, balancing spacers, or other necessary hardware to ensure a proper fit with your existing cabinets.

Other Factors to Consider

Beyond the monetary costs, there are other factors to consider when deciding whether to replace cabinets or just the doors.

Time and Labor

If you're planning to tackle this project as a DIY undertaking, consider the time and labor involved in each option. Replacing just the doors and drawer fronts is generally faster and less labor-intensive than a full cabinet replacement.

That said, if you're hiring a professional to perform the work, the labor costs for each option will likely be similar, unless the layout of your cabinets needs to be changed, which would increase the labor cost for a full replacement.

Design Considerations

Replacing just the doors and drawer fronts can completely change the look and feel of your kitchen. If you're looking to update your kitchen's style, consider the various door styles and materials available to achieve your desired aesthetic.

For example, if you're aiming for a modern farmhouse look, you might opt for shaker-style doors with a slight distressed finish. For a more contemporary feel, sleek slab doors in a high-gloss finish might be the way to go.

Ultimately, the best option for you will depend on the condition of your existing cabinets, your budget, and your design goals. By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision that will enhance the functionality and beauty of your kitchen.