Grammar and smartness might seem interlinked, with 'smart' often used to describe someone who's linguistically adept. But the phrase 'is more smart' is not grammatically correct. Let's delve into grammar, correct usage, and the misconception around 'smart' as an adjective.
In English, 'smart' as in 'intelligent' is normally accompanied by a limiting adjective, like 'very', 'quite', or terms indicating comparison, such as 'more' or 'most'. However, saying 'more smart' is grammatically incorrect due to a little-known linguistic quirk.
Understanding the Correct Usage of 'Smart'
First, let's understand how to correctly use 'smart' in common contexts. We typically use it with a modifier, like "He is quite smart," or "She is very bright."
This is because 'smart' in this context is a relative adjective. Unlike absolute adjectives (like 'red' or 'big'), relative adjectives need a standard of comparison to be grammatically sound. In this case, the standard is implicit: compared to others, or England's average intelligence quotient (IQ), etc.
Using 'More' with Relative Adjectives
'More' can be used with relative adjectives, for example, "She is more smart than her siblings," or "He is more intelligent than the average student." Here, 'more' specifies a comparison that goes beyond general relativity.
However, 'more smart' without a comparison target is erroneous because it doesn't specify the standard against which the person is 'more' intelligent. In formal grammar, such comparisons need a clear standard of comparison, almost always expressed by a clause or a comparative phrase.
'Smart' as a Noun and Adjective in Other Contexts
'Smart' is also used as a noun, meaning someone with an aptitude for learning (e.g., "Doctors need to be smart to succeed.") and an adjective to describe things that are designed demonstrate intelligence, like 'smart' phones or 'smart' homes. These uses don't apply to the 'smart' as intelligence, which needs a modifier or comparative.
The back-formation theory suggests 'smart' as an adjective once derived from 'smartness' or 'smartly', and using it without a standard of comparison might seem natural because many speakers incorrectly assume 'smart' to be an absolute adjective. Nevertheless, it is not.
The Misconception Around the Intelligence
Part of the confusion arises from the misconception that IQ (a measure of intelligence) is an absolute scale. It is not. It is a relative measure, and IQ's value is only meaningful in comparison with others'. Thus, 'more smart' is an oxymoron of sorts, seeking to imply comparison without actually doing so.
A quick check: ask yourself, "More smart than whom?" If you can't answer, then something's amiss in your sentence. As a general rule, avoid 'more smart'; use 'more intelligent', 'more clever', or 'more brainy'βall accurately comparative.
Embracing correct grammar is not just about accuracy; it's about clarity and nuance. Even minor inaccuracies can muddle our intended messages. So, let's strive for 'more' understanding, 'more' patience, and 'more' accurate language use.