◆Smart Home Ideas Journal

Original Kmart Sub Recipe: Ingredients List & Secrets

By

If you're a fan of retro snacks, then you might have a soft spot for those classic Kmart cafeteria favorites. One treat that stands out is their original Kmart sub recipe, a delicious combination of ingredients that has left many customers craving more. While Kmart's(sub) stands are no longer a feature in their stores, we've got the next best thing - a breakdown of the original Kmart sub recipe ingredients and a guide on recreating this iconic sandwich at home.

Before we dive into the ingredients, let's take a moment to appreciate the nostalgia wrapped up in this humble sub. Once a staple in Kmart stores, these subs were more than just a quick lunch; they were a social gathering spot, a familiar aroma that welcomingly greeted shoppers, and a reminder of simpler times. Now, let's honor that legacy by reviving the Kmart sub in our own kitchens.

The Original Kmart Sub Recipe Ingredients

The key to recreating the original Kmart sub lies in sourcing the right ingredients and understanding the unique preparation techniques. While we can't guarantee that our homemade version will taste exactly like the ones you enjoyed at Kmart, we'll certainly get you pretty close.

a sub sandwich with lettuce and tomato on it next to some potato chips
a sub sandwich with lettuce and tomato on it next to some potato chips
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Lunch Counter Classic
Kmart Sub Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Lunch Counter Classic
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs

So, let's gather our ingredients and get ready to step back in time. Here's a breakdown of the original Kmart sub recipe ingredients:

Bread

At the heart of every Kmart sub was their signature Italian bread. Soft on the inside, with a crisp crust, and large enough to accommodate an ample filling. To authentically recreate the Kmart sub, invest in a quality Italian sub roll with a similar texture and size.

an advertisement for a kmart sub sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes
an advertisement for a kmart sub sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomatoes
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Sub Sandwiches

To achieve that slightly chewy interior and golden crust, consider using a good-quality Italian bread recipe or, if you're short on time, opt for an artisanal bakery sub roll. For an extra touch of nostalgia, you could even shape your homemade bread dough into Kmart's distinctive ' miniature baguette' style roll.

Meat

The original Kmart sub was notorious for its generous meat servings. A combination of thinly sliced deli ham, turkey, and Italian salami was commonly used. To replicate this, opt for high-quality, low-sodium deli meats and ensure they're thinly sliced.

For an authentic touch, consider visiting a local deli or specialty store that offers bespoke meat slicing. This will not only help you achieve the correct thickness but also allow you to select the finest quality meats available.

K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
KMart Submarine Sandwiches
KMart Submarine Sandwiches
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs
Kmart Subs
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches
K-Mart Sub Sandwiches

-assemble the Vegetables and Condiments

With the bread and meats sorted, let's turn our attention to the supporting cast of vegetables and condiments that make the Kmart sub a symphony of flavors.

Pro Tip: Preparation is key here. Make sure to slice your veggies uniformly for easy assembly and a pleasant eating experience.

Produce

No Kmart sub would be complete without an assortment of crisp, fresh vegetables. A classic combination included crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and thinly sliced red onions. For an added crunch, some variations included sliced bell peppers as well.

the facebook page shows an image of several hamburgers with different toppings on them
the facebook page shows an image of several hamburgers with different toppings on them
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
Kmart Subs - a Blast from the Past! Recipe - Food.com
a menu for a sub sandwich with meats and vegetables on the side, along with instructions to make it
a menu for a sub sandwich with meats and vegetables on the side, along with instructions to make it
a wooden cutting board topped with different types of meats and veggies on it
a wooden cutting board topped with different types of meats and veggies on it
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Kmart Sub Sandwiches
Copycat Kmart Sub Recipe - The Food Hussy
Copycat Kmart Sub Recipe - The Food Hussy
Mr. Submarine Sub Sauce
Mr. Submarine Sub Sauce
Nostalgic Kmart Submarine Sandwich Recipe
Nostalgic Kmart Submarine Sandwich Recipe
Does anyone know how to make a Kmart sub sandwich? - Answers
Does anyone know how to make a Kmart sub sandwich? - Answers
an image of the facebook page with text on it
an image of the facebook page with text on it
a sandwich with ham and cheese on it is shown in an advertisement for kmart's submarine sandwiches
a sandwich with ham and cheese on it is shown in an advertisement for kmart's submarine sandwiches
ingredients to make ham sandwiches laid out on a marble counter top with text overlay
ingredients to make ham sandwiches laid out on a marble counter top with text overlay

To ensure the freshest veggies, opt for seasonal produce where possible. Nothing beats the taste of a ripe, juicy summer tomato or crisp winter lettuce.

Condiments

The key to a great Kmart sub was finding the right balance between creamy and tangy condiments. A spread of mayo on one half of the roll, and a combination of mustard and Italian dressing on the other, was a common choice. Some patrons also added a drizzle of vinegar for an extra zing.

When selecting condiments, always opt for the best-quality ingredients. This doesn't necessarily mean expensive; rather, choose products with natural ingredients and minimal preservatives.

Cheese

While not a mandatory component, some Kmart subs were topped with a generous helping of shredded cheese. If you're a cheese fan, consider shredding some mild cheddar or Monterey Jack cheese to sprinkle over your sub before assembly.

For an authentic touch, you could even toast your sub after assembly, allowing the cheese to melt and the bread to develop a light crunch.

Assembling Your Homemade Kmart Sub

Now that we have all our ingredients prepped and ready, it's time to put it all together. Assembling the Kmart sub is where you can truly channel your inner cafeteria cook and test your sandwich-making skills.

Remember, the key to a great sub lies in the layers. Don't be afraid to pile it high, but ensure each bite still has a little bit of everything. Here's a simple step-by-step guide:

Step 1: Spread

Start by spreading a generous helping of mayo on one half of the roll. Be sure to cover the entire surface, right up to the edges.

Next, apply a thin spread of mustard on the other half of the roll. While some folks favored a generous slathering, a light touch will allow the other flavors to shine through.

Step 2: Layer

Now comes the fun part - loading up your sub with all those delicious ingredients you've prepared. Start with a layer of lettuce on the mustard side, followed by a generous serving of meat.

Next, add your sliced veggies - tomatoes, onions, and peppers (if using). A drizzle of Italian dressing and a sprinkle of cheese (if using) should follow. Repeat these layers on the mayo side, ensuring your sub has a balanced distribution of each ingredient.

Step 3: Secure

Finally, bring the two halves of your sub together, and gently press down. You want to create a sandwich that's well-assembled but not squished - finding that sweet spot between structural integrity and optimal flavor delivery.

Slice your sub in half, and then again into thirds, yielding six perfectly portioned pieces. Serve immediately and enjoy the fruits of your labor.

And there you have it - a nostalgic journey down memory lane, punctuated by the delightful flavors of the original Kmart sub recipe. Whether you're a lifelong fan or a curious cook seeking a new challenge, we hope this article has inspired you to recreate this classic sandwich at home. Happy cooking, and until next time, remember that some things are definitely worth preserving on a posteriori slice of bread.