The age-old question of "Is it more smart or more smarter?" might seem trivial, but it actually sparks an interesting discussion about language evolution and its rules. To understand this, let's delve into the world of grammar and linguistics.
English, like many other languages, is a complex system of rules and conventions that changes over time. This evolution can lead to debates about the 'correct' way to use the language, as seen in this particular case.
The Jade Jagger Conundrum
In an interview, Jade Jagger, daughter of Mick Jagger, sparked this debate when she said, "I'm the most smarter person in my class." This statement, while grammatically incorrect, brought the question of 'smart' vs. 'smarter' to the forefront.
Many people argued that 'smarter' is the correct comparative form of 'smart'. But as we'll see, the answer isn't as straightforward as it seems.
Rule 1: The Basic Comparative
In standard English grammar, most adjectives form the comparative by adding '-er' to the base form. For example, we say 'faster' instead of 'fasterest' and 'bigger' instead of 'biggerest'. So, following this rule, 'smarter' should indeed be correct.
However, the base form of 'smart' already ends in '-t', so adding '-er' might seem redundant. Additionally, some purists argue that a separate comparative form should exist for such words, like 'better' for 'good'.
Rule 2: Superlative Form
When it comes to superlative forms, most adjectives add '-est' to the base form. So, we have 'fastest', 'biggest', and 'smartest'. This seems to support the existence of 'smarter' for comparative forms, as we should theoretically say 'smartest' for superlative.
However, the superlative rule doesn't always hold for words ending in '-t'. For instance, we say 'oldest' for the superlative of 'old', not '*oldestest'. This adds more confusion to the debate.
Exceptions and Histories
English is riddled with exceptions and irregularities, and 'smart' appears to be one of them. Historically, 'smarter' was indeed the accepted comparative form. However, over time, usage has shifted, and 'more smart' has gained traction.
In current usage, while 'smarter' is not grammatically incorrect, 'more smart' is often preferred, especially in formal or precision-heavy contexts. Various style guides and language experts recognize this shift and encourage using 'more smart' for clarity and consistency.
Use of 'More' with Adjectives
While 'more' is typically used with nouns ('more books'), it can also be used with adjectives for certain nuanced purposes. For instance, 'more curious' implies a higher degree of interest than 'curiouser' might suggest.
In the case of 'smart', using 'more smart' can emphasize the degree or extent of smartness, rather than just comparing it to another instance.
The Role of Context
The 'smart' vs. 'smarter' debate also highlights the importance of context in language usage. What's considered correct in one context might be frowned upon in another. For instance, in academic writing, precision is crucial, and 'more smart' might be preferred to avoid ambiguity.
Conversely, in informal or conversational contexts, 'smarter' might be more appropriate and understood. It's all about choosing the right tool for the job, linguistically speaking.
In the end, language is a living, evolving entity, and the debate around 'smart' vs. 'smarter' is a testament to that. While 'smarter' might be grammatically correct, 'more smart' is gaining ground and is widely accepted in many contexts. So, while it's important to understand the rules, it's also crucial to adapt and evolve with our language. After all, language is a tool we use to communicate effectively and efficiently, and as such, it should be used flexibly and judiciously.