Before delving into the query "is smarter a word or is it more smart", let's consider the context. We're exploring a debate that often arises around comparative adjectives and their usage. However, before we can engage in this linguistic duel, we must first understand the structure of the English language and the role of comparatives within it.
In English, adjectives are used to modify or describe nouns. Comparative adjectives, as the name suggests, are used to compare the quality of two or more nouns. They usually follow the pattern of 'adjective + er', with the exception of a few irregular comparative forms like 'better', 'worse', and 'more'. This brings us to the crux of our discussion: "Is it 'smarter' or 'more smart'?"
Comparative Adjectives in English
As mentioned, most comparative adjectives follow a simple pattern. You take the positive form of the adjective (e.g., 'smart'), add '-er' to the end (e.g., 'smarter'), and off you go. However, not all adjectives follow this rule.
In some cases, especially when modifying abstract nouns or uncountable quantities, we use 'more' instead of adding '-er'. For example, 'more happy' is used to compare levels of happiness, and 'more interesting' is used to compare levels of interest.
Comparing 'Smarter' and 'More Smart'
'Smarter' aligns with the general rule of comparative adjectives. It directly compares two individuals, indicating that one person is intellectually superior to another. For instance, "John is smarter than Paul."
On the other hand, 'more smart' can be used to compare two persons in terms of their intellectual capacity rather than their intelligence. However, this usage is less common and some linguists argue that it's grammatically incorrect. Here's an example: "Tom is more smart than Harry." While some people might understand what you mean, it's generally more grammatically correct to say "Tom is smarter than Harry."
Comparing Abstract Nouns
In the case of abstract nouns, 'more' is usually the correct comparative form. For example, "This idea is more interesting than that one." Here, we're comparing two ideas based on an abstract quality, 'interesting'.
However, even in these cases, 'smarter' can sometimes fit the context. For instance, "This solution is smarter than that one" could mean that the solution is more intellectually superior or clever, even though it's referring to an abstract concept.
What Does the Data Say?
To further understand the usage of 'smarter' and 'more smart', one can analyze data from recognized sources. On Google Ngram Viewer, which compares the frequency of phrases in books, 'smarter' significantly outranks 'more smart'. This suggests that in literary context, 'smarter' is more commonly used.
Moreover, usage statistics from sources like the Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA) support the prevalence of 'smarter' over 'more smart'. According to COCA, 'smarter' appeared approximately 70 times more often than 'more smart' in the analyzed time frame.
Which is Correct?
While 'more smart' is technically grammatically correct in some contexts, 'smarter' is the more common and conventional usage in the English language. It aligns with the typical comparative adjective structure and is accepted by major style guides.
Therefore, in most day-to-day conversations and written communications, 'smarter' would be the preferred and more natural choice to convey the comparative concept of intelligence.
So, let's 'get smarter' about language and embrace the most natural and widely accepted form of comparative adjectives in English. After all, smart is smarter than we think.