The question, "Is it smarter or more smart?" is an interesting one, as it touches on the semantics and usage of a common adjective - 'smart'. But is there really a difference between the two?
English is a complex and evolving language, and the rules can sometimes seem arbitrary. So, let's delve into the details to understand this seemingly minute difference.
Understanding the Base Form - 'Smart'
'Smart' is an attribute adjective, meaning it describes a quality or state that a subject has. It means having or showing quick intelligence or ability.
When we use 'smart', we're typically highlighting a single instance or describing a characteristic that's inherent to something or someone.
'Is it smart?'
"Is it smart?" is a question that asks about the presence of intelligence or ability in a single occurrence or entity. It's looking for a yes/no answer.
For example, "Is that cat smart?" - Here, you're asking about the intelligence of a specific cat, not comparing it to other cats or intelligence levels.
'It is smarter than...'
"It is smarter than..." is a comparative sentence. It's used to compare two things, showing a difference in intelligence or ability.
For instance, "My new puppy is smarter than my old one." Here, you're comparing the intelligence of two puppies, with your new puppy showing more intelligence than the old one.
Introducing 'More' - A Degrees of Comparison
'More' is a determinant that indicates a greater quantity or degree. When we combine 'more' with 'smart', we get 'more smart', which sounds unnatural to most English speakers.
This is because 'smart' is not typically an adjective that can take 'more'. Instead, we use 'smarter' for this purpose, which is the comparative form of 'smart'.
'This is more smart...'
"This is more smart than..." is not grammatically correct because 'smart' doesn't form comparatives in the same way as other adjectives.
For example, saying "This is more smart than that." would be incorrect. Instead, we would say, "This is smarter than that."
'Is it more smart than...?'
"Is it more smart than...?" doesn't make grammatical sense either. Instead, we would ask, "Is it smarter than...?"
For instance, "Is the new phone smarter than the old one?" Here, you're asking if the new phone has more intelligence or ability in a specific area than the old one.
So, in conclusion, while 'smart' and 'smarter' are used interchangeably in many contexts, when it comes to comparing intelligence or ability, 'smarter' is the correct term to use. It's not just about being smarter, but also about recognizing the appropriate grammatical structure in English.